Sunday, 17 November 2013

Filled Under: , , , , ,

Proto-globalisation in the Indian Ocean World and network approaches

Last weekend I attended the concluding conference of the ERC-funded Sealinks project. The Sealinks group, headed by Nicole Boivin of Oxford University, has investigated the early maritime links that connected societies on the Indian Ocean rim, using primarily evidence produced by archaeobotany, zooarchaeology, genetics and linguistics. Many results have already come out, and these shed light on processes going further back in time and having more profound and lasting impact, than those evident from earlier studies based on artefactual, epigraphic and literary evidence.

The conference gathered researchers working with biological and environmental proxies, along with with traditional archaeologists and the odd historian. Indian Ocean trade and navigation, as well as the  early history of globalisation being among my other research interests, I found the conference immensely informative. It struck me, however, that although almost all presenters used the N-word, there was next to no discussion on what a network is, how past networks can be approached, and what insights this might give. This is not intended as criticism of the work presented, which was generally of very high standard. In fact the observation would be valid for most archaeological conferences I've attended, and I've worked with the Indian Ocean for more than ten years myself before starting consciously to think in terms of networks myself. Indian Ocean connectivity, however, is a subject that would readily lend itself to network approaches, and in this post I'd like to share a few thoughts on how different groups of material might have benefitted from being approached from a network perspective.

Networks of people
My own research on Indian Ocean trade is primarily on merchant networks: how they formed, cohered, operated and interrelated. In my paper in Oxford I argued that merchants from the Syrian city of Palmyra engaged with local and regional social networks of power, ideology/religion and commerce, in the process of expanding their own ethnically based network from the Syrian Desert into Mesopotamia, the Persian Gulf, the Red Sea and the Arabian Sea. Our data on merchant networks are of literary, epigraphic and ceramic nature – the Palmyrene network for instance being attested by circa 50 inscriptions recording the presence or activities of Palmyrene groups and individuals in settings certainly or very likely connected with Indian Ocean trade. Similar data would be possible to utilize for other groups. Ingo Strauch and collaborators for instance recently published more than 200 inscriptions in Arabic, Indic, Ethiopic, Aramaic and Greek script from a sanctuary in the cave of Hoq on the island of Socotra. Many of these should be possible to connect with places of origin, religion, language, and script used, reconstructing the network that intersected at the node of Hoq in a manner that would be possible to approach by the toolbox of Social Network Analysis.

Networks of objects
New inscriptions are occasionally still discovered, but in general, the written evidence relevant to ancient Indian Ocean trade is delimited and finite. The archaeological data available from Indian Ocean settings, however, has exploded over the last two decades, following major excavation projects  and better practices of documenting, identifying and publishing finds. In my opinion, there are cases where distribution patterns are not necessarily well suited for network analyses, as the presence of objects does not always reveal how, when and by which routes and agents they moved from point of origin to find-spot. In the case of the Indian Ocean, however, distribution patterns clearly do have potential for network analyses, as distances, topography and climate led to virtually all communication taking place by sea. Network analysis based on distribution patterns of ceramics, beads and glass – goods that can be traced to place of production on stylistic, chemical and petrographic grounds, could clearly reveal directions, bottlenecks and clustering of trade.

Networks of places
Clearly, the same would be the case with settlements. Attempts at modeling relationships between ports and their hinterlands and between ports, based on size, kinds of imports and exports, period of occupation, distance to other centers, season of navigation etc. might help us think about why some places and some regions were important, while others seem to not to have been taking part in long-distance exchange to the same extent.

Networks of genes
Many of the papers in Oxford were on the movement of crops, animals and people, studied by way of genetic material recovered from archaeological sited. Dispersal of genes was in most cases visualized by phylogenetic trees. This is of course also a network analysis, showing genetic connections between the varieties of crops etc. found in different settings. If sufficient numbers of dated examples exist from a sufficient number of sites, I think these would also be good for showing patterns of prehistoric seafaring.
 
sex dictionary sex diseases sex education film sex facts for teenagers sex health tips sex medicine for male sex good for health sex positions during pregnancy sex power medicine sex relationships sex related words Vibrators and Adult Toys sex pills for women sex relationships online dating business online dating catfish online dating elite online dating guide Adult Superstore sexuality counseling sex facts and tips sexuality confusion sex power medicine sex relationships sex related words Vibrators and Adult Toys sex pills for women sex relationships Free Online Casino Free Online Slots Games Online Casino Games the best online casino games Winning Strategy Games Best Gaming Experience Play Online Casino Games Online Casino gambling best casino gambling Slots gambling Online Casino Reviews The Best Online Casino Play Online Casino Games Play Online Casino Play Online Pokies Real Money Slots Online Slots and Casino Play Online Slots Real Money Casinos Play Slot Machines Online Real Casino Jackpot Party Casino Slots Real Casino Slots Apps sex dictionary sex diseases sex education film sex facts for teenagers sex health tips sex medicine for male sex good for health sex positions during pregnancy sex power medicine sex relationships sex related words Vibrators and Adult Toys sex pills for women sex relationships online dating business online dating catfish online dating elite online dating guide Adult Superstore sexuality counseling sex facts and tips sexuality confusion online dating tips online dating scams online dating service sex good for health sex positions during pregnancy sex power medicine Find a Home Inspector Online Home Inspector Home Inspection Tips Patio Furniture Home and Patio Decor Center Home Patio Better Home Products home product business Home Remedies Kitchen Appliances Online Home Security Systems The Best Smart Home Security Systems Wireless Home Security Systems Home Design Ideas Home Decorating Ideas interior design ideas bedroom Bedroom Designs Small Bedroom Designs The Best Carpet Cleaner Carpet Cleaning Machines Best Home Builders Home Building Online Courses Home Builder Marketing Glass Shower Screens House of Flooring Top Living Room Flooring Better Homes and Gardens Best Logistics Software Best Application Comparison Shipping Software Solutions Logistics Management Software Logistics Software Systems Software Developers Systems Software Developers Software Engineer Software Developer Education Android Software Applications Most Popular Software Applications Cell Phone Monitoring Software Software Technology Technology Applications Phone System Software Information Technology Spy Phone Technology download Smartphone Spy Phone Technology Logistics Software Systems Software Developers Systems Software Developers Software Engineer Software Developer Education Android Software Applications Most Popular Software Applications Cell Phone Monitoring Software Software Technology Technology Applications Best Application Comparison Shipping Software Solutions Hotel and Travel Vacations and Travel Deals Cheap Hotels Travel Tips Travel Guides Travel Information Cheap Flight and Hotel Packages‎ Trip Travel Insurance Compare Cheap Holiday Travel Insurance Find Cheap Hotel Discounts Cheap Hotels and Flights Best Restaurants Chinese restaurants Vegetarian Restaurants Hotels And Resorts Best Hotel Restaurant Travel Information Cheap Flight and Hotel Packages‎ Trip Travel Insurance Compare Cheap Holiday Travel Insurance Find Cheap Hotel Discounts Cheap Hotels and Flights Vacations and Travel Deals Cheap Hotels Travel Tips Travel Guides Travel Insurance Find Cheap Hotel Discounts Addiction Causes Causes of Alcohol Addiction Causes of drug addiction Drug Abuse Information Substance Abuse Programs Choosing a Addiction Rehab Program Drug Rehab Treatment Information New Drugs Online Personal product Sell Products Online Marketing Product Product Research Analyst Product Research Facilitator The Food Products General Products Beauty Products Business beauty product skin care beauty salon product online product Marketing Products to Advertise online shop originals Product Personal product Sell Products Online Marketing Product Product Research Analyst Product Research Facilitator The Food Products General Products Beauty Products Business beauty product skin care beauty salon product online product Marketing Products to Advertise Product Research Analyst Product Research Facilitator online product The Lawyer The Business Law Bankruptcy Lawyer Law Firms Legal Information Attorney Best Lawyers Justice Laws Website The Law Society Justice Law Limited Personal Injury Lawyer Justice and Law Studies The Justice Law Group Law and Justice Division Justice and legal Commercial lawyer Corporate Commercial Law Criminal Justice Degree Schools Criminal Justice Online Degree Programs School of Criminal Justice Bankruptcy Lawyer Lawyer Requirements Lawyer Employment Specialities of Forex Trading Online Forex Trading Forex Trading Best forex training Forex trading news sites Trading Stock Market Trading Trading Technologies Online Stock Trading Market Trading Online Equity Trading Market Trading Online Equity Trading Trading Central Make Money Online Forex Trading Secure Trading Forex Trader Best forex training Forex trading news sites Start Trading Trading Wedding Wedding Ideas Virgin on Wedding Night wedding definition quotes wedding definition of marriage find the meaning of wedding Wedding Planning Wedding Planning Guide Wedding Websites wedding planning tips Small Wedding Planning Wedding Wedding Ideas Virgin on Wedding Night wedding definition quotes wedding definition of marriage find the meaning of wedding Wedding Planning Wedding Planning Guide Wedding Websites wedding planning tips Small Wedding Planning Wedding Planning Guide Wedding Websites Wedding Ideas Wedding Ideas small business Virgin on Wedding Night wedding definition quotes wedding definition of marriage Personal product Sell Products Online Marketing Product Product Research Analyst Product Research Facilitator The Food Products General Products Beauty Products Business beauty product skin care beauty salon product online product Marketing Products to Advertise online shop originals Product Personal product Sell Products Online Marketing Product Product Research Analyst Product Research Facilitator The Food Products General Products Beauty Products Business beauty product skin care beauty salon product online product Marketing Products to Advertise online shop originals Product Marketing Product Product Research Analyst Product Research Facilitator online product Best Logistics Software Best Application Comparison Shipping Software Solutions Logistics Management Software Logistics Software Systems Software Developers Systems Software Developers Software Engineer Software Developer Education Android Software Applications Most Popular Software Applications Cell Phone Monitoring Software Software Technology Technology Applications Phone System Software Information Technology Spy Phone Technology download Smartphone Spy Phone Technology Logistics Software Systems Software Developers Software Engineer Software Developer Education Android Software Applications Most Popular Software Applications Cell Phone Monitoring Software Software Technology Technology Applications Best Application Comparison Shipping Software Solutions Marketing Concept Affiliate marketing Smart Affiliate Marketing Strategies Best Affiliate Marketing Networks Best Affiliate Programs Digital marketing Internet Marketing Services digital transformation Seo Web Marketing Web Marketing Ecommerce Marketing Strategy Ecommerce Marketing and Technology Marketing Concept Affiliate marketing Smart Affiliate Marketing Strategies Best Affiliate Marketing Networks Best Affiliate Programs Digital marketing Internet Marketing Services Internet Marketing Services Online Business Digital marketing Ecommerce Marketing Strategy Marketing Strategy E-Commerce Technology Digital Marketing Ecommerce Marketing and Technology Managing E-Commerce Marketing Future Technology Health Information Technology Latest Technology Modern Technology New Technology 2017 Science And Technology Technology Technology Articles Technology Definition Technology in Business Technology in Education Technology in Medical Technology News Technology Review What Is Information Technology What Is Technology World Wide Technology List of Information Technology IT Staffing and Solutions Master of Technology in IT Software Quantum Information Digital Forensics Forensic Technology Software Reference Library Technology in Education Drug Abuse Addiction Causes Causes of Alcohol Addiction Causes of drug addiction Drug Abuse Information Substance Abuse Programs Choosing a Addiction Rehab Program Drug Rehab Treatment Information New Drugs Online Pharmacy and drugs Drug Rehab Center Alcoholism Rehab Center Start a New Life after Rehab Drug Rehab Treatment Programs Addiction Causes Causes of Alcohol Addiction Causes of drug addiction Drug Abuse Information Substance Abuse Programs Choosing a Addiction Rehab Program Drug Rehab Treatment Information New Drugs Online Pharmacy and drugs Drug Rehab Center Alcoholism Rehab Center Start a New Life after Rehab Drug Rehab Treatment Programs Drug Abuse Information Substance Abuse Programs Drug Rehab Center Online Shopping Ladies Apparels Online Fashion Shop Shoes Shop Bags Online Clothing Shopping Online Dresses Shopping Shop Wedding Dresses Online Shopping Electronics Market Global Shopping Womens Accessories Shop jewellery and bags Online Shop Accessories Latest fashion handbags Cheap Bags Online Wholesale Handbags Designer Bags and Purses Fashion Online For Women Women's Clothing Accessories Online Shopping Clothing Online Shop Ladies Fashion Online Wholesale Handbags Online Dresses Shopping Shop Wedding Dresses Online Shopping Electronics Market Global Shopping Online Shop Accessories Online Shopping Ladies Apparels Online Fashion Shop Shoes Shop Bags Online Clothing Shopping Online Dresses Shopping Shop Wedding Dresses Online Shopping Electronics Market Global Shopping Womens Accessories Shop jewellery and bags Online Shop Accessories Latest fashion handbags Cheap Bags Online Wholesale Handbags Designer Bags and Purses Fashion Online For Women Women's Clothing Accessories Online Shopping Clothing Online Shop Ladies Fashion Online Wholesale Handbags Online Dresses Shopping Shop Wedding Dresses Online Shopping Electronics Market Global Shopping Womens Accessories Shop jewellery and bags Online Shop Accessories Auto Parts Auto Repair Advice Guide Automotive Electrical Systems Automotive Group Auto International rent car guide Automotive Advertising Agencies Vehicle Electrical System Online Drivers Education Auto Parts and Service Auto Repair Shop Auto Parts Suppliers Auto Repair Shop Auto Body Parts Online Auto Body Parts vehicle's maintenance Driver Training Schools Auto Parts and Service Online Drivers Car Education Online Drivers vehicle technologies electrical Auto Parts and Service technology supports autocar driver education requirements Online Programs Driver Education Vehicle Electrical System Driver Education Online AP Electric Vehicle Market Web Development Webshop Seo Web Marketing Web Tool Development Websites cheap price Free Web Design SEO Consulting Services Web Marketing Web Design Web Design projects Web Design Jobs Online Online Web Development Course real estate luxury condos Commercial Property For Sale Commercial Real Estate Commercial property Apartments for rent apartment finder service Find Apartments for Rent Apartment Luxury Homes Real Estate Developments Mortgage Rates Best Mortgage Rates real estate luxury condos Commercial Property For Sale Commercial Real Estate Commercial property Apartments for rent apartment finder service Find Apartments for Rent Apartment Luxury Homes Real Estate Developments Mortgage Rates Best Mortgage Rates Commercial Property For Sale Commercial Real Estate Commercial property Best Mortgage Rates Hotel and Travel Vacations and Travel Deals Cheap Hotels Travel Tips Travel Guides Travel Information Cheap Flight and Hotel Packages‎ Trip Travel Insurance Compare Cheap Holiday Find Cheap Hotel Discounts Cheap Hotels and Flights Best Restaurants Chinese restaurants Vegetarian Restaurants Hotels And Resorts Best Hotel Restaurant Travel Information Cheap Flight and Hotel Packages‎ Compare Cheap Holiday Travel Insurance Find Cheap Hotel Discounts Cheap Hotels and Flights Vacations and Travel Deals Cheap Hotels Travel Tips Travel Guides Travel Insurance Find Cheap Hotel Discounts